Media Reactor vs Media Bag: Pump, Tubing, and Cabinet Fit

Decide between a media bag and a reactor. Check pump flow, tubing size, footprint, and cabinet clearance against the exact manual before buying.

Gear · By the Coral Compass team ·

Quick answer: A media bag in a high-flow spot is enough for short, occasional carbon runs. A reactor earns its place when you run GFO continuously or want even, controlled contact. Before buying one, confirm the pump, tubing, footprint and lid clearance against the exact manual. Many reactors ship without a pump or hose.

Print the worksheets or paste them into your own notes; nothing you write is saved. It covers hardware fit only; for phosphate targets and how fast to lower phosphate, see phosphate in reef tanks.

Bag or reactor: what each media needs

MediaFlow behaviour the sources describeBag enough?
Activated carbonLow flow; granules should not move or tumble (Simplicity Aquatics). The PhosBan Reactor 150 manual says the whole column can be filled when running only carbon.Often, for short runs in a high-flow area. A reactor gives more even contact. See activated carbon for media choice.
GFO (granular ferric oxide)Low flow; the top layer should move slightly (Simplicity). The PhosBan manual says to adjust until granules tumble slightly at the surface, and not to use a media bag in that reactor.Usually not for continuous use. Reefstead’s guide notes a static clump in a bag mostly uses its outer layer.
BiopelletsHigh flow; pellets must tumble, and no sponges (Simplicity).No. They need a reactor designed for pellets; see denitrification options.

Simplicity Aquatics, which sells filter media, says a reactor beats a bag because it increases contact time, and that media in a high-flow sump or overflow area is a more economical but less efficient alternative. It also describes most reactors as reverse-flow: water goes down a centre tube and back up through sponge, media and sponge. These are a seller’s general statements, not measurements for your tank.

An exact manual: what one reactor actually requires

Here is why “fits most tanks” is not enough. These are the published figures for one long-running upflow reactor, the Two Little Fishies PhosBan Reactor 150, from its operating instructions and the LiveAquaria specification table. They are manufacturer figures, not our test, and not a recommendation over other reactors.

SpecPublished figureWhat you check
Media capacityUp to 200 g (385 ml) of PhosBan, or 5 in (13 cm) of media; minimum 2 in (5 cm) of GFOHow much media your tank and your phosphate plan call for
Tank sizeOne reactor for up to 150 gallons; several for larger tanksYour total system volume
Flow through the mediaAbout 20–30 gal/hr (75–115 l/hr); too much flow can grind the mediaA valve you can reach to set it
Feed pumpNot included; pump of 100–200 gph capacity throttled with the supplied ball valve, or tap off an existing pumpA spare pump or a tee off your return, plus an outlet
Hose1/2 in (12.7 mm) inside diameter; hose not included; the ball valve goes on the inlet, never the outletTubing length and route from pump to reactor and back
Size4-1/2 × 4 × 17-1/2 in high (LiveAquaria listing)Cabinet height plus room to open the lid and lift out the centre tube
PlacementUpright in the cabinet, in the sump, on the floor below the tank, or hanging on the side or rearWhich of those spots you actually have

What throttling to 20–30 gal/hr means

The PhosBan manual calls for a 100–200 gph pump throttled to 20–30 gal/hr with the supplied ball valve. Worked out, the valve passes 20–30% of a 100 gph pump's flow (20 ÷ 100 to 30 ÷ 100) and only 10–15% of a 200 gph pump's (20 ÷ 200 to 30 ÷ 200).

The valve is doing most of the work, which is why this page keeps asking for a spot you can reach. The pump's own manual should say whether it's happy running throttled that hard, so check it before you pair the two.

Fit worksheet: measure before you buy

CheckMy measurementExact model’s requirement / sourcePass / unknown
Cabinet interior height under any brace or sump lip________________________________________________
Height needed to open the lid and lift out media________________________________________________
Footprint: reactor base plus valve and hose bends________________________________________________
Sump section with room and depth for a feed pump________________________________________________
Tubing inside diameter and run length________________________________________________
Spare outlet or controller port for the pump________________________________________________
Drip path: what sits below the reactor if a fitting leaks________________________________________________

Measure the space you will actually service, not the empty cabinet. A reactor that fits standing up may not open under a brace. Keep the valve where you can reach it, because flow is adjusted by watching the media.

Complete the missing-parts list

ItemAlready haveMissing / verifyBuy or reuse
Reactor body, sponges and lid seal________________________________________________
Feed pump (or tee from an existing pump)________________________________________________
Tubing of the right inside diameter, and clamps________________________________________________
Flow valve (inlet side)________________________________________________
Media________________________________________________
Phosphate test kit to judge the media________________________________________________

Buy, reuse, or skip

SituationDecisionWhat settles it
You run carbon a few days at a time and have a high-flow spotKeep using a bagSwap and rinse it on schedule; a reactor is optional
You plan continuous GFOA reactor is usually worth itConfirm flow, pump, tubing and lid clearance for the exact model
You already own a reactor that passes the worksheetReuse itReplace worn sponges or seals per its manual rather than the whole unit
No space or no reachable valve positionSkip or relocateHang-on or under-tank placement only if the manual allows it
Phosphate is already in range and stableSkip the purchaseMedia and hardware cannot improve a number that is already where you want it

Example: the brace that decides it

Fictional worksheet example: a reactor’s footprint fits beside the skimmer, but the cabinet brace leaves less room than the owner needs to open the lid and lift out the centre tube. Result: skip that position. The options are a different mounting spot the manual allows, a shorter model whose published height fits, or staying with a bag.

Frequently asked questions

Is a media bag enough for carbon?

Often, for short or occasional runs in a high-flow area. A reactor gives more even contact; Simplicity Aquatics calls a bag in a high-flow area the more economical but less efficient option.

Can I put GFO in a bag inside a reactor?

Not in the PhosBan Reactor 150: its manual says not to use a media bag and to fill 2 to 5 inches of loose GFO. Check your own reactor’s manual.

Do I need a separate pump?

Many reactors do not include one. The PhosBan Reactor 150 manual lists everything except the hose and pump and calls for a 100–200 gph pump throttled to 20–30 gph with its ball valve.

Sources and what they cover

Sources checked Nov 9, 2026. The worksheets and the fictional example are original planning aids, not hands-on product tests. Confirm the current revision and parts list with the manufacturer before ordering.

If the worksheet shows a gap

The link goes to the carbon and GFO media reactors category, not a specific reactor model or stock check. Keep your existing bag or reactor when it already does the job. If it doesn't, use the completed worksheet to confirm media, parts and current availability with the retailer or manufacturer.

Disclosure: Coral Compass may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Retailer links are marked as sponsored, and this doesn't change what we recommend. Full disclosure.

← All gear guides